One year on from the start of the crisis, violations of migrants’ rights continue in Tunisia

05/04/2024

 

One year on from the start of the crisis, violations of migrants’ rights continue in Tunisia

More than a year after the President of the Republic of Tunisia’s statement following a meeting of the National Security Council linking the presence of migrants to “a plot to alter the demographic composition of Tunisia”, systematic violations and racist and xenophobic campaigns targeting sub-Saharan migrants in the country continue unabated.

The policies of successive governments have continued to bow to the dictates of the European Union in the externalisation of its borders, delegating security management and border surveillance to the countries of the southern Mediterranean. This outsourcing is accompanied by the pitting of financial aid, subsidies, and loans to be paid to southern countries on the condition that they agree to play the role of the EU’s border guards. These measures have been ratified within the framework of various agreements with different countries neighbouring the European Union to the south. They continue scorning the fundamental basis of any equitable partnership, which can only be founded on a balanced relationship of mutual respect between the countries of the Global North and the Global South.

In addition to intercepting migrants in national territorial waters, the Tunisian National Guard also endeavours to pursue them within the country, notably by arbitrarily displacing them, disregarding humanitarian considerations and the international conventions signed and ratified by Tunisia. These violations occurred in several regions of the country, where security forces decided to push migrants towards rural, peri-urban areas, notably in El Aamra, El Jédériya, and Kasserine, where their situation is becoming increasingly worrying and alarming.

It is also important to recall the disastrous consequences of the forced displacement of migrants by the Tunisian authorities to the desert buffer zone along the Tunisian-Libyan border since this past summer, under the blazing sun, denying them access to the aid that organisations and citizens were trying to provide them.

Faced with this horrific situation, particularly the worrying conditions of people on the move who were in the city of Sfax, the Tunisian authorities responded solely from a security perspective, ignoring the human and humanitarian dimensions.

In this context, it is essential to also highlight the relentless actions taken by the security apparatus since March 19, 2024 against the former president of the Association of African Students and Interns in Tunisia (AESAT), Christian Kwongang, a Cameroonian citizen. These actions included his arbitrary detention in the El Ouardia Centre.[1]

It should also be stressed that several people testify to the direct involvement of the Tunisian authorities in the violence perpetrated against migrants, both during interception operations at sea[2] and during removal interventions on land.[3]

 

In view of the above, the signatory organisations and associations wish to:

  • Express their concern at the serious and systematic human rights violations suffered by migrant workers, as well as the systematic campaigns of incitement to hatred and violence, and call for investigations to reveal the truth and prosecute the perpetrators of these violations.
  • Express their total solidarity with the AESAT, condemn the harassment of Christian Kwongang, and demand immediate guarantees that his rights will be respected.
  • Demand clarifications on the basis and legal framework for the detention of migrant persons, including at the El Ouardia Centre, which operates outside of any framework or judicial supervision, in blatant violation of Tunisian laws and of the international conventions ratified by Tunisia, as was confirmed by the decision of the Administrative Court in 2020.[4]
  • Condemn the European Union’s border security and outsourcing policies, which undermine human rights, and call on the Tunisian state to respect national and international law with regards to people on the move, and to reject all European border externalisation policies.

Signing organisations

  1. Ligue tunisienne des droits de l’homme – LTDH
  2. Forum Tunisien pour les Droits Economiques et Sociaux – FTDES
  3. Association Lina Ben Mhenni
  4. Calam
  5. Legal Agenda
  6. Association Intersection pour les Droits et les Libertés
  7. Avocats Sans Frontières – ASF
  8. Association Mada
  9. Comité de Vigilance pour la Démocratie en Tunisie
  10. International Service For Human Rights – ISHR
  11. L’association Sentiers-Massarib جمعية مسارب
  12. Beity
  13. WeYouth Organization
  14. Association TaQallam pour la liberté d’expression et de créativité (جمعية تكلّم من أجل حرية التعبير والابداع)
  15. Association Ifriqiya
  16. Al Khatt
  17. Inkyfada
  18. African Business Leaders
  19. Aswat Nissa
  20. Association Tunisienne de Défense des Libertés Individuelles – ADLI
  21. No Peace Without Justice
  22. Association Nachaz-Dissonances
  23. Coalition Tunisienne Contre la Peine de mort – CTCPM – الائتلاف التونسي لالغاء عقوبة الاعدام
  24. Organisation Contre la Torture en Tunisie – OCTT – المنظمة  التونسية لمناهضة التعذيب
  25. Association pour la Promotion du Droit à la Différence – ADD
  26. Comité pour le Respect des Libertés et des droits de l’Homme en Tunisie – CRLDHT
  27. Fédération des Tunisiens pour Une citoyenneté des deux rives – FTCR
  28. Union des Travailleurs immigrés Tunisiens – UTIT
  29. Al Bawsala
  30. Nawaat
  31. Stop Pollution
  32. لطفي عزالدين ،محام،عضو الهيئة الوطنية للوقاية من التعذيب
  33. DAMJ
  34. Minority Rights Group – مجموعة حقوق الأقليات
  35. EuroMed Rights
  36. Migreurop
  37. A Buon Diritto
  38. CCFD-Terre Solidaire
  39. ARCI
  40. Watch The Med – Alarm Phone
  41. Associazione per gli Studi Giuridici sull’Immigrazione – ASGI

Sami Bargaoui, universitaire

Monia Ben Hamadi, journaliste

Hechmi BEN FREJ militant

Insaf Machta, universitaire

Walid Mejri, journaliste et activiste (وليد الماجري، صحفي وناشط)

Marta Luceño Moreno

Chokri Latif, Ecrivain – شكري لطيف – كاتب

Fayçal Ben Abdallah, président de la FTCR

Mouhieddine Cherbib, président du CRLDHT

Fathi TLILI, président de l’UTIT

Mohamed Ben Saïd, FTCR/ CRLDHT

Mourad ALLAL, CRLDHT

Mohsen DRIDI, FTCR

Kamel JENDOUBI, CRLDHT

Patrizia Mancini

Hamadi Zribi

Zaineb Mhemdi

[1] https://ftdes.net/ar/la-dignite-humaine-bafouee-en-detention-et-aux-frontieres/?fbclid=IwAR1KLWTfa6Qq8thGR09mEnCXpg_iORMNjlZarttnuKCM-lRhvEQfb2TGJww

[2] https://www.france24.com/fr/afrique/20230629-les-gardes-c%C3%B4tes-tunisiens-mis-en-cause-dans-le-naufrage-de-migrants-subsahariens

[3] https://www.lemonde.fr/afrique/article/2023/10/16/en-tunisie-les-autorites-continuent-de-chasser-des-migrants-a-la-frontiere-algerienne_6194823_3212.html

[4] المحكمة الادارية تصدر قرارا بإيقاف ايواء مجموعة من المهاجرين بمركز الاستقبال والتوجيه بالوردية – الإذاعة التونسية (radiotunisienne.tn)

Civil society organizations in Tunisia commemorate. National Day Against Impunity

Tunisia on March 31, 2024.
Civil society organizations in Tunisia commemorate. National Day Against Impunity
on March 31st “Until when the State can escape its responsibility?”
March 31, 2018 marks the sixth anniversary of the drowning death of young Omar Abidi, who was chased by a number of police officers from the Olympic Stadium in Rades to the level of Wadi Mellian on March 31, 2018. For years now, civil society groups in Tunisia call upon the authorities to officially recognize March 31 as a national day against impunity.
While public opinion in Tunisia may be shocked after receiving news that someone has been subjected to torture or ill-treatment, the occasional feeling of shock and”temporary” solidarity with one of the victims quickly fades. In general, public opinion wants to stick to the idea of torture being a “marginal” phenomenon with isolated cases. Over the past years, civil society organizations have documented hundreds of cases of torture affecting direct victims and their families alike. The conviction rate diverges towards zero.
Impunity also reigns in cases of torture or ill-treatment, resulting in suspicious deaths. Witness testimonies or medical reports issued in this context often conclude that the deaths were natural, while the victims’ families and reports by human rights organizations indicate that the victims died in contexts that are shrouded in mystery.
The lack of convictions is largely due to the incompatibility of the definition of torture in the Tunisian Criminal Code with the UN Convention against Torture, which Tunisia ratified in 1988. The crime as stipulated in the Tunisian Criminal Code is more restrictive and does not cover all the objectives of the act stipulated in the international definition, fostering impunity.
The Tunisian Criminal Code also does not regulate the time limits for investigation except when the accused is in pre-trial detention. Too often, complaints remain unanswered on office shelves, and even if an investigation is authorized, the period between the filing of the complaint and the date of the first hearing is extensive. At the trial stage, the accused rarely appear before the court with the tacit encouragement of the Ministry of Interior taking impunity to another institutional level.
On this occasion, the signatories of this statement reaffirm their commitment to continue the struggle to eradicate the scourge of torture, which is fueled by a culture of impunity, and call for Establishing March 31 as a national day against impunity.
Revising article 101 bis of the Tunisian Criminal Code criminalizing torture, to bring it into line with article 1 of the UN Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.
Revising the Tunisian Code of Criminal Procedure to establish time limits for both preliminary investigations and judicial inquiries in cases of torture and ill-treatment.
Ensuring the presence of defendants during all stages of the trial.
Proceeding with pending cases and holding all those involved in crimes of torture and human rights violations accountable.